My “Chocolate Day” Haul (and what I plan to do with it)

The day after Valentine’s Day has become a cultural holiday in and of itself. My daughter calls it “Chocolate Day” because that’s when the stores mark down Valentine candy. She has learned from her mother (*wink, wink*) that the candy beneath the pink & red, heart-covered wrapper tastes exactly like the regular stuff. It just costs less! So she is the one who kept reminding me that we needed to go “Chocolate Day” shopping.

Chocolate, Of Course!

I hit several area stores after Christmas and still have some candy sealed in glass jars from that expedition. Remembering where I found the best prices, I drove her straight to a certain grocery store and we made a beeline for the “seasonal” aisle. The aisle had been ransacked like the bread aisle before a snowstorm, but we still found the bargains we wanted!

I took advantage of "Chocolate Day" discounts to stock up on a few items I'll want for future holidays and gifts. | A Chat Over Coffee

I took advantage of “Chocolate Day” discounts to stock up on a few items I’ll want for future holidays and gifts. | A Chat Over Coffee

Hershey Kisses were at the top of my list because I use them to make peanut blossom cookies. The recipe is one I learned from my grandmother but I’ve seen it since in cookbooks and online. This simple little concoction is perfect when you just want a few cookies for the family because it’s quick, easy, and only makes about a dozen and a half.

Before I make the cookies I’ll sort the Kisses by wrapper color. The red ones will be used for cookie baking and the pink & white ones will be saved for Resurrection Sunday treats.

Peanut Butter/Peanut Blossom Cookies
from A Chat Over Coffee

What You’ll Need:

  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1 cup granulated sugar, plus extra for coating
  • 1 egg
  • About 18 Hershey Kiss candies, unwrapped, if you want peanut blossoms

    You can make peanut butter cookies quickly and easily with only three ingredients! | A Chat Over Coffee

    You can make these peanut butter cookies quickly and easily with only three ingredients! | A Chat Over Coffee

What to Do:

  • Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
  • Thoroughly mix the peanut butter, 1 cup sugar, and egg. Roll the mixture into 1″ balls. Roll the balls in extra sugar to coat.
  • To make regular peanut butter cookies (like those pictured), place the balls about 2″ apart on an ungreased baking sheet. Press a fork into the top of each ball twice, in a criss-cross pattern, to flatten. Bake at 350 degrees for about 10 minutes. Allow the cookies to cool for a few minutes on the baking sheet, then remove them to a cooling rack.
  • To make peanut blossoms, place the balls about 2″ apart on an ungreased baking sheet but DO NOT flatten them. Bake at 350 degrees for about 10 minutes. Remove the cookies from the oven and immediately press the flat side of one unwrapped candy into the center of each cookie ball to flatten it. Do not press the candy all the way through to the baking sheet. The cookies will puff out and crack around the edges. Allow them to cool for a few minutes on the baking sheet, then remove to a rack to cool.

Some of the Reese’s Cups will be used to make chocolate-peanut butter ooey gooey butter cake and some will be sorted out like the Kisses to be used for Resurrection Sunday treats. Others will probably be eaten just as they are long before Resurrection Sunday. Most of the candy is already sealed in my largest Food Saver vacuum canister. The large bag of Reese’s Cups is in the cabinet because I hope to make that ooey-gooey butter cake very soon! (My Food Saver is older, so I linked to something similar that is currently available. I hope that helps!)

Paper Products

And since I’ve been chatting about Resurrection Sunday you might have guessed that the plates and napkins will be set aside for that day. Resurrection Sunday is a working day for a minister’s family. It’s a holiday worth celebrating with fancy dishes and table service but it’s also very impractical for us to do so, which is why I am happy to find cute disposables to keep things in balance. I don’t know yet if we’ll be hosting the family or going to another family member’s home, but I thought I’d plan ahead and get the paper products since these were fun and festive and even less expensive than the dollar store. If we don’t host then I’ll have them available for summer gatherings or the inevitable car picnics that are sure to come as the weather warms up.

I found some good prices on "Chocolate Day" and am planning what to do with my deals. | A Chat Over Coffee

I found some good prices on “Chocolate Day” and am planning what to do with my deals. | A Chat Over Coffee

I realize I might have saved a bit more by waiting for the 75% off sales in a week or two, but I know from experience that the things I actually wanted would be long gone by then. Now that my “babies” are teenagers I don’t have to buy egg hunt candy, which I used to wait and get later at larger discounts. So what did I actually spend? This time I spent $2.14 per bag on the Hershey Kisses and smaller Reese’s Cups and $3.19 for the larger cups. I was sort of annoyed at the cost of the Kisses because they were only $1.88 per bag after Christmas. The paper products were only $.62 each, so you can see why I went ahead and got those.

That’s probably all of the candy buying I’ll do for a while. I may get some treats after Resurrection Sunday to stash for car picnics and that sort of thing, but I’ve also learned that I can’t eat it if it isn’t in the house!

Platypotamus (Say, what?)

My daughter, who loves stuffed animals, bought herself a strange little creature that looks like somebody took spare parts from a hippopotamus and a platypus and stitched them together. She decided to buy him and bring him home because he was the only platypotamus (her word) she’d ever seen. Remembering our recent trip to the theater, she decided to name him Cyrano de Platypotamus. The name and the nose fit.

I mention Cyrano because there were several other cute stuffed toys in the Valentine’s Day section that were pink or red but not necessarily Valentine-y. There were sock monkeys and fish and a very glittery unicorn. Any of them might have been good to stash as gifts for little people. Or teenagers who still love stuffed animals.

Did you shop on “Chocolate Day”? What did you get and where did you find the best deals?

This post contains affiliate/referral links. If you click through and make a purchase I will receive a small referral fee but your price will not change. Your support helps me cover the costs associated with running this site, so thank you very much!

I moderate comments manually but will get them posted as quickly as possible. Please keep your comments kind and if you must disagree please do so without being disagreeable. Rude or inappropriate comments will obviously not be published.

Update: This post was shared at What’s for Dinner? Sunday #32.

12 responses to “My “Chocolate Day” Haul (and what I plan to do with it)

  1. Yes , finding chocolate for a good price is always wonderful. We like peanut blossoms here too, but your recipe is really small. 18 would be about the amount eaten just right off the cooling rack here!

    The Betty Crocker email recipe the other day was for a chocolate gooey butter cake. Is that what you are talking about? It looked like a brownie.

    My youngest (JR in college) still collects stuffed animals. One of her cousins knit her a big bobbly sheep for Christmas, almost as big as the larger pillow pet pillows. She named it Ewerydice. ( She pronounces it the Italian way “dee-chay” instead of “di-see”.

    I have to say at first I had no idea what you meant by Resurrection Sunday. I had to google it. EASTER.
    You mean Easter. Why do you have a different name for it? I found that information on a Catholic site, actually, and I am pretty sure you are not Catholic. We have lots of German and Polish in our area, so many Catholics and Lutherans, too. I know they do many things that we do not…there was just a Fat Tuesday where the churches and stores sell special doughnuts call “paczki”.


  2. There was still quite a bit of Valentine’s chocolate at the store when I checked on Saturday. I bought several bars of white chocolate and milk chocolate that I’m going to chop up and use to make macadamia nut choc chunk bars. They will be for a co-worker’s birthday. (Well and a batch for us too). They are her favorite. Now we can look forward to the next post holiday chocolate haul sale.


  3. Pingback: What’s Cooking? | A Chat Over Coffee·

  4. Pingback: Something to Smile About: Sourdough, Saving, and Spring | A Chat Over Coffee·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s